I'd rather be neither but if I'm mentally tired that usually means I can't shut the brain down and rest. 

Physcially tired. But really, I don't care for either.

Since most days I am mentally tired, it would be wonderful to be physically tired.

 Good morning William. If I had my druthers, I think physically.

I'll go with physically because that means I've probably had a pretty good workout ... and I can still relax with a good game on TV or a good book.

That's a tough one...but I think I would rather be physically tired. 

William Feela Being mentally tired really tires you out physically.

Depending on the situation either will come into play. Prefer it not happen but there are limitations!

Good morning William. It is kind of the same for me. My body will tell me when I need to rest, most of the time I will listen.

Physically.......I know well both and know what that means. 

I've been both and I choose neither...

At my age there is no physical.... LOL

I don't prefer either.

William, the two usually go together.  But physical is better.

I like the feeling of being physically tired. Being mentally tired I don't like so much.

Physically -- it is much easier to recover from it.

Mentally tired. I would know I had accomplished more 

Neither.

Physically!

I seem to be getting plenty of both kinds of tired these days

Definitely physically tired, one good night sleep all good again!

Physically tired is very easy to overcome unlike mentally tired. A

Physically tired. I always sleep really well when I am tired out!

Physical. Speaking from cancer treatment experience, my physical well being came back a long time before my mental well being came back.

Yaaaaawn --- let me think about it for a while.  

Good morning William,

Neither, but both do happen:) If I had to choose an answer it would be mentally tired....I can physically make it to the bed.....

William,
I’ll opt for physically tired over mental any day.

Physically tired for sure ....the mental part comes during the night when I can't sleep!

I would rather be physically tired than mentally tired.

I've been both.  Physically is best.  Mentally... that's zombie status!

physically tired.... I hate being brain dead....

Neither. I am always full of energy until bedtime.

Neither

Physically tired for sure

Physically as one may take a cat nap.

Mentally from what I have seen causes sleep disorder's.

I would rather be physically tired than mentally tired.

I prefer to be physically tired.

Even to the extent I feel pain in those muscles awakened from their dormancy.

That is the validation I need to know I'm really alive, living fully in the moment, to have....a little pain.

Hi William..I'd prefer physically tired. Your body is tired and easier to shut down..mentally tired can lead to to your brain sparking and not wanting to shut off... LOL! 

Neither, but seems like one affects the other with me.

Mentally tired, so I can sleep all night long.

Physically tired would be the best choice for me.

Physically

A little of both works for me.

Neither one!

They're both the same in my book. If my hubby and I are working out in the yard all day long, we become physically tired. If we're working on a demanding IT project all day long, we become mentally tired. Both require a good amount of rest to fully recuperate.

physically any day. mental means bed time

William Feela physically is fine  - mentally 

Probably physically as you usually feel better in the morning after a good night's sleep.

Physically tired.